ACI Blog

Payments modernization is the key to helping credit unions gain and retain younger members

On this page

As a proud credit union member, I have always valued the relationship-based approach that credit unions offer. When entrusting someone with my money or borrowing, the personal connection credit unions foster is incredibly important. Credit unions are a vital part of America’s financial services landscape, providing affordable banking services, promoting financial inclusion, and investing in the communities they serve.

However, the digital transformation that has swept through the banking and fintech industry, along with changes in consumer preferences and an aging customer base, presents several challenges for credit unions. It has been hard for credit unions to create competitive digital banking and payment experiences compared to better-resourced larger banks and fintechs. This has, in turn, created difficulties in attracting and retaining members, particularly younger demographics who are drawn to competitors’ more innovative offerings. At the same time, their relative tech-laggard status has made them an increasingly popular target for fraud.

Credit unions win on values but struggle on payments

Credit unions are struggling to attract younger demographics, which is unfortunate. By not engaging with these age groups, they are losing out on providing lower fees for banking services and lower interest rates on loans. This situation represents a missed opportunity for younger consumers and the credit unions themselves, as their business model and mission align closely with the core values of these younger generations.

Generation Alpha refers to individuals born between 2010 and 2024, comprises around 13% of the U.S. population, and represents the future member base for credit unions. Research shows that, despite their young age, they value helping others and prioritize community and social responsibility.

All else being equal, credit unions would win any financial services popularity contest fought on these grounds. However, things are not equal with digital offerings, which are also extremely important to Generation Alpha.

This generation started using digital devices from a very young age. By the time they become major consumers of financial services, it will be in their nature to expect seamless digital experiences. Yet many credit unions, even some of the largest, do not yet offer alternative payment types like Google Pay, Apple Pay, Zelle, or Venmo. This plays into the perception among younger audiences that credit unions are less technologically advanced than other financial services providers.

The most recent results of ACI’s annual ACI Speedpay Pulse report show that 47% of consumers want to pay their loans with these alternative payment methods. For Gen Z and Millennials, that figure rises to 59% and 61% respectively, but even a healthy 24% of Boomers would pay with a mobile wallet.

Credit unions can give their members a seamless payments experience by offering alternative payments and mobile wallet options. These methods are vital for businesses competing in the digital economy.

2025 priorities: Payments innovation and enhanced fraud defenses

Part of the reason credit unions struggle to keep up with the latest technological advancements is structural: the decision-making boards at credit unions have a lot on their agenda, and they also have various competing priorities for resources and budget.

A key insight on future improvements emerged from a recent conversation with a credit union vice president (VP). This VP expressed pride in the organization’s selective range of services, which leads to high member satisfaction scores. However, he also acknowledged that their limited payment options were a significant weakness in the collections process.

Credit unions frequently contact members with overdue payments by phone, but they typically ask them to visit a branch to make a payment. As we move further into the digital age, the effectiveness of this approach is quickly declining. A much more efficient solution would be to allow members to make repayments over the phone using a debit card or other available payment methods.

This scenario highlights the importance of investing in new payment channels, even if it means incurring some costs for processing in-the-moment payments, which may be a few dollars per transaction. The cost of missing repayments entirely is significantly higher. It also indicates that credit unions could effectively introduce new payment options through their collections process. This could include offering payment methods such as debit cards, Apple Pay, and Google Pay, plus experimenting with self-service options for overdue members, as resources permit.

We can see the risks of not catering to consumer expectations in the research from PYMTS. That study found that 64% of credit union members were interested in seeing their credit union add more payment capabilities, and 27% said they would switch providers for more innovative solutions.

Fraud is becoming an increasing concern for credit unions. The rise of digital banking has introduced new vulnerabilities, which fraudsters exploit in sophisticated ways. To combat this threat, credit unions must prioritize ongoing education for their members about fraud risks and invest in modern, multilayered security measures powered by artificial intelligence.

What makes the ideal payment and fraud modernization partner?

The right payments partner for credit unions embarking on this journey will provide more than just robust and secure technology solutions. They will also offer consultative support services and expertise to ensure the project is delivered efficiently, managing costs and resources effectively.

In addition, an ideal partner will stay ahead of emerging trends and regulatory changes, providing ongoing support and innovation to keep the credit union competitive and secure in a rapidly evolving financial landscape. This holistic approach ensures that credit unions can focus on their core mission of serving their members while confidently navigating the complexities of modern payment and fraud prevention systems.

Need to drive more customer satisfaction? Faster, secure, customized bill pay starts now.

Want regular updates on payment innovation opportunities for lenders? Connect with me on LinkedIn

Senior Business Development Executive

David Williams brings more than seven years of experience in the fintech industry to ACI Worldwide. As a skilled sales engineer and business developer, he has a proven record in the financial services sector. David excels in technical sales, digital marketing, and CRM automation. He is recognized for his strong communication skills with diverse groups, expertise, and dedication to innovation within the payments industry.